
And if that weren’t enough to sell this book, it is accompanied by a CD of the poems read by the poets. Thanks to archival copies, today’s children can hear readings of Robert Frost and Langston Hughes, among others. There are also readings by Nikki Giovanni and J.R. R. Tolkien. Tolkien, I said. Not all of the poems are included on the CD, but enough for an hour’s worth of driving. (Well, when do you listen to CDs?)
And there is still more, because the book involves three illustrators who bring these poems to life. One illustrator may have led to an overly consistent style of art that wouldn’t have reflected the very different kinds of poems. But with three, we get a mix of styles while still keeping a general consistency. It would have been jarring to see radically different art styles, but though the illustrators each bring a unique flavor to the poem, the pictures flow well from one to another.
I have only one complaint. I wish they had not used Carl Sandburg’s “On A Flimmering Floom You Shall Ride,” especially as they used another poem that plays with made-up words, “Jabberwocky,” very soon after it. I can’t imagine why they didn’t use “Fog” instead, which would better represent the poet’s style and would be accessible to children. Now, funny thing, this very poem was Little Willow’s poetry pick for the day. Cool.
I am driving to Virginia Beach tomorrow with my kids, I’m bringing this book, and I’m playing the CD. And we are not leaving that car until one of us comes to appreciate poetry in a new way. With this collection, I’m thinking that this is a pretty safe bet.
4 comments:
I do have a second complaint, but it is about an Amazon review, not the book. One "reviewer" notes that some of the poems are over the head of his 2.5 year old. Reeallly. That is soooo surprising that a book of poetry for children - which at last look I would count til at least age 12 - might be a little hard for a kid in diapers. The book isn't called "Poetry Speaks to Toddlers," dumbass.
Ah, the parents who believe that every single book, ever, should be entirely appropriate for their child. Gotta love them.
Not.
By coincidence, I reviewed Poetry Speaks this week; my library copy of Poetry Speaks to Children hasn't come in yet.
Great minds think alike. :)
I've been meaning to review this book too. Glad you got to it first.
As for parents being overeager, I think it's the competitive parenting epidemic. Obviously, if his or her budding genius wasn't immediately enraptured, it's the book's fault.
I hope you put your review on Amazon above the dumbass's.
Post a Comment